Gold Pick Award Judging Criteria

    Explanation of Judging Process

    The PRSA Colorado Gold Pick Awards focus on recognizing excellence in public relations, and are therefore not limited to one winner in each category.

    While multiple awards will win a Gold or Silver Pick in a given category, our Grand Gold Pick award annually goes to the “best in show” campaign entry that receives the highest overall score.

    Judges should be seasoned public relations and marketing professionals, with four years or more of practice and/or their APR. Two or three judges must evaluate each entry. Professionals with a wealth of experience in specific category topics should judge entries in that category. Conversely, judges who have little experience in an entry's category topic should instead seek out submissions that reflect their area of expertise.

    The judging scale for Campaigns and Components is based on a 40-point scoring scale, with points given to four categories in campaigns: research, planning, execution, and evaluation; and four categories in components: planning/content, creativity/quality, technical excellence and results.

    Component Media Relations entries do not require a Technical Excellence criterion for judging. Total scores for award designation should be based upon a total point count of 25, noted on the score sheets provided.

    CAMPAIGN CATEGORIES – JUDGING CRITERIA

    1. Research
      How thorough and valuable was the research that was conducted? Was the situation adequately and accurately analyzed? Were the research methods appropriate for the situation and/or budget? Did research help to re-define the situation in any way? How was the research relevant to shaping the planning process? How did the research help define the audience(s) or the situation? What hypotheses were drawn as a result of the research findings? (10 points)  

    2. Planning
      How did the plan correlate to the research findings? What was the overall strategy for the program? What were the specific objectives, tactics and budget set for the program? Who were the target audiences? What materials were used? How was the budget set, and how were staff time and resources allocated? Did the plan reach its creative potential? How thorough was the plan? How original was the strategy? (10 points)

    3. Execution
      How was the plan executed and what were the results? Were there any difficulties encountered? If so, how were they handled? Were financial, personnel and other resources used effectively? Was the program completed on time and within budget? How appropriate were the tactics to achieving objectives and executing strategy? How creative were the tactics? How integrated were the various tools with one another? (10 points)

    4. Evaluation
      What method(s) of evaluation were used? Did the results of the program relate to research findings and/or hypotheses? Do results tie back to stated objectives? To what degree did the program meet its objectives? Were the results of the program measured effectively? How successful was the organization in achieving its objectives? Were there continuous opportunities for learning and program refinement? (10 points) 

    ORGANIZATIONAL AWARDS – JUDGING CRITERIA 

    1. Overview 
      Is there a comprehensive overview of the organization along with its accomplishments? Did the entrant clearly define his or her role(s) in the organization? Is their impact measurable? Have they demonstrated the ability to overcome challenges? How have they demonstrated a behavioral or attitudinal change? Have they fostered a good working relationship? (15 points) 

    2. Documentation
      Do the case studies support the goals of the team? Do they demonstrate leadership in PR? Do they follow the principles of PRSA? Have they provided innovative and creative examples of their work? (15 points)

    3. Impact/Results
      Does the team demonstrate excellence in public relations? Have they provided their annual budget or revenue? Do you have a clear understanding of their team members’ expertise? (10 points)
       

        FOR COLLEGE/UNIVERSITY:

        1. Overview 
          Is there a comprehensive overview of the organization along with its accomplishments? Did the entrant clearly define his or her role(s) in the organization? Is their impact measurable? Have they demonstrated the ability to overcome challenges? How have they demonstrated a behavioral or attitudinal change? Have they fostered a good working relationship? (15 points) 

        2. Documentation
          Do the case studies support the goals of the team? Do they demonstrate leadership in PR? Do they follow the principles of PRSA? Have they provided innovative and creative examples of their work? (15 points)

        3. Impact/Results
          Does the team demonstrate excellence in public relations? Have they provided their annual budget or revenue? Do you have a clear understanding of their team members’ expertise? (10 points) 

        4. Accreditation

          Do they have a PRSSA chapter? Do they have a Certificate in Education for Academic Programs in Public Relations (CEPR)? If not, or not clearly provided, zero points for this section. (5 points)

        COMPONENT CATEGORIES – JUDGING CRITERIA

        1. Planning/Content
          Are the objectives for the use of the particular tactic clear and concise? Was the object or goal of the entry thoughtfully considered, clearly stated and attainable? Was the audience identified? Was a clear strategy stated or implied? (10 points) 

        2. Creativity/Quality
          Do messages tie to objectives? Is content substantive, understandable, consistent and appropriate for the stated audience? How is the entry unique? How is the tool used imaginatively to achieve program goals? (10 points) 

        3. Technical Excellence
          Do graphic or communications elements set the entry apart? Is production quality superior, based on budget and scope of the project? (10 points) 

        4. Results
          What effort was made to assess whether the measurable objective(s) or stated goal was met? Did the entry meet its stated intent? Are there other indicators of success, quantitative or qualitative, in meeting objectives? (10 points) 

        Award Designations

        Entries that average total points in the following ranges will merit these awards: 

        Campaigns
        36-40 Gold Pick
        32-35 Silver Pick

        Organizational Awards
        36-40    Gold Pick
        32-35    Silver Pick

        Components – Non Media Relations
        32-40    Gold Pick
        29-31    Silver Pick

        Components – Media Relations
        25-30    Gold Pick
        22-24    Silver Pick